The Molly Miller case: 'We're going to get answers' - KTEN.com - Texoma news, weather and sports

The Molly Miller case: 'We're going to get answers'

Posted: Updated:
Molly Miller and Colt Haynes disappeared in July, 2013. (KTEN) Molly Miller and Colt Haynes disappeared in July, 2013. (KTEN)
Paula Fielder is leading efforts to locate her cousin, Molly Miller, who disappeared in 2013. (KTEN) Paula Fielder is leading efforts to locate her cousin, Molly Miller, who disappeared in 2013. (KTEN)
James Conn Nipp is the last person known to have seen Molly Miller and Colt Haynes. (Carter County) James Conn Nipp is the last person known to have seen Molly Miller and Colt Haynes. (Carter County)
Law enforcement officers searched near the area where Molly Miller and Colt Haynes were last seen in July, 2013. (File/KTEN) Law enforcement officers searched near the area where Molly Miller and Colt Haynes were last seen in July, 2013. (File/KTEN)

WILSON, Okla. -- It's now been almost six years since two young Texomans went missing.

The disappearance of Wilson residents 17-year-old Molly Miller and her 21-year-old friend Colt Haynes on July 8, 2013 remains a mystery, but family members haven't lost hope that they will soon get the answers they have been waiting for.

"She was just a very sweet, very sweet little girl," said Molly's cousin Paula Fielder. "Never in my life did I think it would go on this long. When Molly's mother called and said, 'I need you here, they've done something to her,' I came, and I mentally haven't left."

Fielder said the search for some type of closure is a daily process.

"And for it to go on almost six years is beyond belief for me," she said. "I don't understand how people can live with the knowledge of what happened to these two and not say anything."

Authorities say James Conn Nipp was the last person seen with Molly and Colt during a high-speed chase through Love and Carter counties, with Nipp behind the wheel.

"Molly and Colt were never seen again from that night, that we are aware of," Fielder said.

The last place investigators traced the pair to was the rural intersection of Oswalt and Long Hollow roads, about 13 miles southwest of Ardmore.

"It's frustrating as the DA not having more leads that we can work on," said District Attorney Craig Ladd.

Nipp was later arrested and pleaded guilty to evading a police officer during that chase. He was released in 2018 after four years behind bars, but he has never been charged in connection with the disappearance of Molly Miller and Colt Haynes.

"You know, cold cases where you believe someone may be deceased and may have died at the hands of foul play, they're very important to us," Ladd said. "Those are the ones that are a little frustrating when you're in law enforcement, and we're sure hoping that we can get some sort of a break in this case that can lead to holding people accountable -- assuming that foul play occurred."

But Paula Fielder hasn't lost hope. She senses there will be a break in the mystery this year.

"I feel it in my gut," she said.

With the help of the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation and sheriff's departments in Carter and Love counties, Fielder is determined to get justice for Molly and Colt, saying new searches are planned soon.

"There's new things that have come around in the past seven months that leads me to believe were going to get answers," she said.

Fielder said not a single day goes by that she doesn't think about Molly.

"If what I've heard happened to her is true, it's going to be a very sad day to hear it officially. It's all speculation at this point. One day, in a court of law it will be told," Fielder said. "As much as people would love for me to go away and stop, it's never going to happen. Molly and Colt deserve better than this."

The OSBI along with Molly's family have established a $45,000 reward for answers that would lead to finding her. There is also an active Facebook page: Operation Find Molly Miller.

  • Submit a News Tip

    Do you have a news tip for KTEN?

    Begin by entering your email address in the field below or call 903-548-4010

    * denotes required fields
    We're sorry, but only one entry is allowed per person.
    Thank you for your continued interest.

    Your news tip has been submitted. If you provided contact information, we might use it to reach out to you if additional information is required.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Sculpture serves as a reminder to "Click it or Ticket"

    Sculpture serves as a reminder to "Click it or Ticket"

    A unique sculpture reenacts a deadly crash that claimed the life of a 16 year old teen serves as a reminder to always buckle upA unique sculpture reenacts a deadly crash that claimed the life of a 16 year old teen serves as a reminder to always buckle up
    A unique sculpture reenacts a deadly crash that claimed the life of a 16 year old teen serves as a reminder to always buckle upA unique sculpture reenacts a deadly crash that claimed the life of a 16 year old teen serves as a reminder to always buckle up

    SHERMAN, Texas --  A unique sculpture in downtown Sherman serves as a reminder to buckle up by reenacting a deadly crash that claimed the life of a 16 year old teen from Spring, Texas. 

    More >>

    SHERMAN, Texas --  A unique sculpture in downtown Sherman serves as a reminder to buckle up by reenacting a deadly crash that claimed the life of a 16 year old teen from Spring, Texas. 

    More >>
  • Third arrest made in Johnston County homicide

    Third arrest made in Johnston County homicide

    Destinee Hutcherson was arrested in connection to a Johnston County homicide.Destinee Hutcherson was arrested in connection to a Johnston County homicide.
    Destinee Hutcherson was arrested in connection to a Johnston County homicide.Destinee Hutcherson was arrested in connection to a Johnston County homicide.

    The Johnston County Sheriff's Office has made a third arrest in connection to the murder of 48 year old Stephen Simonds who's body was found near a creek in a rural area in Coal County Thursday.  

    More >>

    The Johnston County Sheriff's Office has made a third arrest in connection to the murder of 48 year old Stephen Simonds who's body was found near a creek in a rural area in Coal County Thursday.  

    More >>
  • Sherman police investigating possible drive-by shooting

    Sherman police were investigating a possible drive-by shooting Friday nightSherman police were investigating a possible drive-by shooting Friday night
    Sherman police were investigating a possible drive-by shooting Friday nightSherman police were investigating a possible drive-by shooting Friday night

     Police were called to the 800 block of North Throckmorton near Carter Street around 9:30 p.m. Friday night after residents reported hearing gunfire.  

    More >>

     Police were called to the 800 block of North Throckmorton near Carter Street around 9:30 p.m. Friday night after residents reported hearing gunfire.  

    More >>